By
I spent a Tuesday morning walking a Home Hardware yard in Ontario with the owner, going truck by truck, coffee going cold in both our hands. Six units. By the third — a 2019 F-550 flatbed with 140,000 km on it and a transmission that had already been rebuilt once — I had a pretty good idea where this was headed. By the sixth, I had a number I almost didn't want to say out loud: **$180,000.** That's what his fleet had bled over five years in costs nobody was tracking. Not fuel. Not the repair bills he already knew about. Just decisions that got made a little too late, or not at all, because nobody was watching full-time.
He wasn't careless. He'd been running the store for eleven years and knew building materials better than almost anyone in the province. He just didn't have anyone watching the fleet the way he watched everything else. Most building centres don't. It's nobody's full-time job, so it quietly becomes nobody's job at all.
Most stores buy a truck, run it until it complains, then start shopping. In between, nobody's tracking:
- When depreciation curves say sell, versus when the truck "still runs fine"
- Whether the spec still matches the loads three years later
- What OEM pricing and lead times are doing this quarter
- Whether the compliance paperwork (weights, axles, safety) is actually current
- What resale value is quietly disappearing while a truck sits past its window
None of that shows up on a P&L line called "fleet mismanagement." It shows up as slightly-too-high repair bills, a truck that's wrong for the route, a replacement that costs more because you waited, or a driver stuck idling in the yard on a truck that isn't ready. It's death by a thousand small decisions, not one big mistake — which is exactly why it's so easy to miss until someone adds it all up. Working through fleets across the country, the same five gaps show up over and over. Here's what they actually looked like on his lot:
1. Replacement timing: That F-550 was the textbook case. I'd have moved it 20 months earlier — instead it sat, "still running," while its resale value quietly eroded. On a $70K unit, that gap is usually $8K–$12K in eaten depreciation. Multiply that across a fleet and it adds up fast.
2. Mis-specs: One of his tandems was doing single-axle work in town for half the week — short runs, tight lots, no need for the extra axle it was hauling around. It had never been the right truck for that route; it was just the truck that happened to be available when he bought it.
3. Bad timing on the market: He'd ordered two trucks during a stretch when lead times and pricing were both working against him, simply because nobody was watching for the window when they weren't.
4. Compliance drift: Nothing had failed yet. But two units were carrying paperwork that hadn't been touched since the day they were bought — the kind of thing that's invisible right up until an inspector asks for it.
5. Reactive maintenance. The pattern across the fleet was "run it until it breaks, then fix it" rather than "know what's coming and plan around it." Reactive repairs on his shop's own numbers ran about 30% higher than the same work done on a planned schedule.
For that Ontario dealer, it was mostly #1 and #5 — two trucks kept a full replacement cycle too long, and a habit of fixing instead of planning that had quietly cost more than trading in on schedule ever would have.
We didn't do anything complicated. I go through his fleet with him a few times a year — what's aging out, what the market's doing, what still fits his routes — the same way I'd want someone watching my own equipment if I didn't have the time to do it myself.
The first review was mostly just triage: flag the F-550 for retirement, get eyes on that mis-specced tandem, pull the compliance paperwork current on both units that needed it. Nothing urgent, nothing dramatic — just things that had been sitting unattended. Six months later, the F-550 sold at close to the number we'd projected instead of whatever it would have fetched another year down the road. By the one-year mark, the tandem had been swapped for a single-axle Moffett setup better suited to his in-town routes, and his shop's own repair log showed fewer emergency call-outs than the year before. Eighteen months in, when I asked him what changed, he put it simply: "I stopped finding out about problems after they'd already cost me something."
That's really the whole shift. Nothing on this list requires a new hire or a new system — it requires someone actually looking, on a schedule, before the truck forces the conversation.
If you've already got someone on staff tracking replacement cycles, market timing, and spec decisions across your fleet, you don't need this — you're already doing it. This is for the stores where fleet decisions get made in the gaps between everything else, which, honestly, is most of them.
You don't need to become a fleet expert. You need someone watching the fleet the way you'd watch it yourself, if you had the time. That's usually the whole gap. If you want a second set of eyes on your fleet before your next purchase — no charge, no pitch, just a look at what you've got and what it's costing you — that's a conversation I'm glad to have.
